
Red · Paso Robles · United States
Herman Story First Time Caller Petite Sirah
Scored from 85 calibrated Vivino reviewers. Cohort: Red · United States (1,156 wines).
94.2%
Global percentile
vs. all 69,234 ranked wines
85.4%
In-cohort percentile
Red · United States · 1,156 wines
—
AI-adjusted percentile
85 calibrated reviewers
Find this wine: view on Vivino · compare prices on Wine-Searcher
Is First Time Caller Petite Sirah a good wine?
Summary
Herman Story First Time Caller Petite Sirah is a red from Paso Robles, the United States. The cheapest 750 ml listing found for it is $64.99, which puts the bottle in the $60–120 band.
85 Vivino reviewers are calibrated for this bottle, and those are the ones the calibrated score reads; a separate, broader pool of 85 reviewers with at least two ratings each feeds the raw-average track. Its in-cohort standing is measured against 1,155 other reds from the United States, not against the corpus as a whole.
- Cohort
- Red · United States · 1,156 wines
- Calibrated reviewers
- 85
Cohort: Red · United States
Closest peers
Questions about this rating
Is First Time Caller Petite Sirah actually good?+
First Time Caller Petite Sirah sits in the 94.2% percentile against every wine we rank, meaning it scores above 94.2% of them.
How does First Time Caller Petite Sirah compare to similar wines?+
Within Red · United States, First Time Caller Petite Sirah lands in the 85.4% percentile. The cohort comparison exists because a global rank flatters or punishes a wine for its category rather than its quality.
How many reviewers is First Time Caller Petite Sirah's score based on?+
85 calibrated reviewers stand behind First Time Caller Petite Sirah's score.






