
Red · Mendoza · Argentinien
Caro (Catena and Rothschild) Malbec
Scored from 79 calibrated Vivino reviewers. Cohort: Red · Argentinien (21 wines).
Grape · Malbec
45.9%
Global percentile
vs. all 69,234 ranked wines
60.0%
In-cohort percentile
Red · Argentinien · 21 wines
—
AI-adjusted percentile
79 calibrated reviewers
Find this wine: view on Vivino · compare prices on Wine-Searcher
Is Malbec a good wine?
Summary
Caro (Catena and Rothschild) Malbec is an Argentine red from Mendoza.
79 Vivino reviewers are calibrated for this bottle, and those are the ones the calibrated score reads; a separate, broader pool of 82 reviewers with at least two ratings each feeds the raw-average track. Its in-cohort standing is measured against 20 other reds from Argentina, not against the corpus as a whole.
- Cohort
- Red · Argentinien · 21 wines
- Calibrated reviewers
- 79
Cohort: Red · Argentinien
Closest peers
Questions about this rating
Is Malbec actually good?+
Malbec sits in the 45.9% percentile against every wine we rank, meaning it scores above 45.9% of them.
How does Malbec compare to similar wines?+
Within Red · Argentinien, Malbec lands in the 60.0% percentile. The cohort comparison exists because a global rank flatters or punishes a wine for its category rather than its quality.
How many reviewers is Malbec's score based on?+
79 calibrated reviewers stand behind Malbec's score.






