Is The Mermaid The Alligator actually good?

The Mermaid The Alligator sits in the 91.8% percentile against every hotel we rank, meaning it scores above 91.8% of them.

How does The Mermaid The Alligator compare to similar hotels?

Within Key West · Upscale, The Mermaid The Alligator lands in the 93.4% percentile. The cohort comparison exists because a global rank flatters or punishes a hotel for its category rather than its quality.

How many reviewers is The Mermaid The Alligator's score based on?

229 calibrated reviewers stand behind The Mermaid The Alligator's score.

Key West, Florida

The Mermaid The Alligator

Name: The Mermaid The Alligator
Address: 729 Truman Ave, Key West Florida Keys, Florida, United States
Price range: $226 - $528

Bed and Breakfast$550 / night· High($$$ Upscale)

91.8%

Global percentile

vs. all 39,171 ranked hotels

93.4%

In-cohort percentile

Key West · Upscale · 62 hotels

94.4%

AI-adjusted percentile

25 calibrated reviewers

Click any photo to enlarge

Amenities

Free Parking
Breakfast Included

Amenities, property type and nightly rate as published on TripAdvisor.

Is The Mermaid The Alligator a good place to stay?

Cohort: Key West · Upscale · 62 hotels
Calibrated reviewers: 25
Method: How percentiles are computed

Source page: TripAdvisor listing →

Book this hotel →

Same cohort · Key West · Upscale

More upscale hotels in Key West Florida Keys

Orchid Key Inn
92nd percentile · 1,698 reviewers · $550/night (High)
Almond Tree Inn
91st percentile · 2,238 reviewers · $500/night (High)
L Habitation Guesthouse
91st percentile · 349 reviewers · $550/night (High)
Marrero s Guest Mansion
91st percentile · 739 reviewers · $650/night (High)
Speakeasy Inn Rum Bar
90th percentile · 160 reviewers · $600/night (High)
Southernmost Point Guest House
90th percentile · 240 reviewers · $500/night (Average)