How to read wine scores: ratings and percentiles
By Ryan Siegal · Founder and Principal
·
What does each kind of number tell you?
| Critic points | A reviewer’s assessment under that publication’s scale and tasting conventions. Read the note and the publisher’s scoring guide. |
|---|---|
| Community stars | Ratings contributed by users of a platform. Check the scale, sample size and whether the displayed rating covers your vintage. |
| Global percentile | Rankquant’s relative position across its ranked wine population on a 0–100 scale. |
| In-cohort percentile | Relative position within the named wine group. The current wine groups use wine type and country. |
| AI-adjusted percentile | Where available, a percentile after sample-size shrinkage. The calculation is arithmetic, not a tasting by an AI model. |
Read publishers on their own terms
JancisRobinson.com's scoring guide describes a twenty-point system and explains that a score depends on the wine's style, the tasting and perceived potential. Its reviews come from a team, not just Jancis Robinson. A high score for one style does not make it interchangeable with an equally scored wine of another style. Read the named reviewer's note alongside the number.
Vivino describes a one-to-five-star community scale. Its decimal-rating feature also allows a user to enter a rating such as 3.8. Those stars are not Rankquant percentiles. Multiplying a star rating by 20 changes the numeric range; it does not establish an equivalent critic judgment or a rank among wines. A population-level correlation also cannot guarantee an equivalent score for a particular bottle.
A measured Rankquant example
In the Rankquant data inspected on November 7, 2026, the record for Elmstone Sauvignon Blanc from Marlborough, New Zealand has the values below. The record does not specify a vintage. These figures describe that stored record; they should not be presented as a rating for a particular harvest year or as a new tasting performed on the inspection date.
| Global percentile | 88.4 across a ranked wine catalog of 69,234 entries. |
|---|---|
| In-cohort percentile | 97.1 within White · New Zealand; the record gives a group size of 1,064 wines. |
| Calibrated reviewer count | 594 reviewers counted in the normalized score. The broader raw-average sample contains 603. |
| Vintage and adjusted score | Neither a specific vintage nor an adjusted percentile is supplied in this detail record. |
The different percentiles reflect different comparison populations. The 97.1 value does not mean a 97.1-point critic rating, and 88.4 is not the percentage of drinkers who liked the wine. A missing adjusted score does not erase the available reviewer count. Counts and score availability must be read separately.
A checklist for comparing two bottles
- Match the identity. Check producer, cuvée, vintage and bottle format. When a record lacks a vintage, do not assume it describes the year on your bottle.
- Identify the judgment. Look for the reviewer or community, the tasting date and the scoring guide. Read any comments about maturity or drinking window.
- Read the sample. A count of calibrated reviewers and a broader count need not be the same. Neither is a guarantee that the wine suits your taste.
- Check the comparison group. Rankquant's current wine cohort is based on wine type and country, not a promised match on vintage, appellation or price.
- Keep price and preference in view. Compare the actual offer and the style you enjoy. No single score threshold establishes that a bottle is good value or that a lower-scoring bottle is flawed.
Frequently asked questions
Can I convert a 20-point score or a star rating into a Rankquant percentile?+
Is a 95-point critic score the same as the 95th percentile?+
Why can a wine have reviewers but no adjusted percentile?+
For the calculation and its limits, read the Rankquant methodology. Use the wine catalog to compare the displayed global and in-cohort percentiles, then verify the identity and context of each wine.